Heavy Metal Reference Guide and Discgraphy


Site Login
Message Board!

Newest Additions
Newest Comments
Audio Samples
Top 100 Rated CDs
Band Homepages
Cover Songs
Submit CDs to BM
Links

About the Site
Site Contributors


View Bands by Genre:
Classic Metal (501)
Christian Metal (38)
NWOBHM (55)
Power Metal (316)
Progressive Metal (165)
Speed/Thrash (270)
Death Metal (145)
Black Metal (56)
Doom (23)
Doom-Death (29)
Sludge Doom (9)
Stoner Doom (9)
Atmospheric Metal (19)
Folk Metal (12)
Gothic Metal (41)
Grindcore (5)
'90s Alternametal (42)
Industrial Metal (19)
Rap Metal (11)
Defies Classification (41)

THE Heavy Metal Reference on the Internet!

Bands: 1768     CDS: 6601     Songs: 75370

   


(Banner ads are FREE for bands and labels. Email me if interested.)

Donate $50    Donate $20    Donate $10    Donate $5    Donate $2   
Your ongoing support of Brutal Metal is appreciated!

#s A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
Compilations    Soundtracks

Top 100!

This is a list of the top 100 highest rated CDs here at Brutal Metal, of those that have received 4 or more votes. This list is not updated in real time, meaning that ratings are only updated when the list is recompiled.

NOTE: The rating system has completely changed. It is now based on a score from 0 to 100. Only one vote per user counts towards the average rating; subsequent ratings simply change their existing rating.

Last updated Sun Mar 30 21:21:01 2025

Rank Average Rating
(1-100)
Number of
Votes
Artist CD

1 94.77 13Queensryche Operation Mindcrime
2 94.70 10Black Sabbath Heaven And Hell
3 94.06 18Iron Maiden Powerslave
4 94.00 5Dio Holy Diver
5 93.94 18Judas Priest Defenders of the Faith
6 93.80 10Judas Priest Metal Works '73-'93
7 93.75 4Metallica Live Shit: Binge And Purge
8 93.71 14Helloween Keeper of the Seven Keys Part II
9 93.67 9Queensryche Empire
10 93.64 14Judas Priest British Steel
11 93.60 5Black Sabbath The Dio Years
12 93.55 11Black Sabbath Headless Cross
13 93.54 13Helloween Keeper of the Seven Keys Part I
14 93.50 6Avantasia The Metal Opera
15 93.18 17Iron Maiden Seventh Son Of A Seventh Son
16 93.18 17Judas Priest Screaming for Vengeance
17 93.08 13Megadeth Rust in Peace
18 93.00 5Exciter Unveiling the Wicked
19 93.00 13Iron Maiden Piece Of Mind
20 93.00 16Iron Maiden The Number Of The Beast
21 92.71 7Judas Priest Unleashed in the East (Live in Japan)
22 92.50 8Black Sabbath Paranoid
23 92.50 6Dream Theater Images and Words
24 92.44 9Crimson Glory Transcendence
25 92.33 6Accept Balls to the Wall
26 92.27 15Iron Maiden Somewhere In Time
27 92.25 8Crimson Glory Crimson Glory
28 92.00 4Helloween Pink Bubbles Go Ape
29 91.89 9Judas Priest Priest...Live!
30 91.75 4Primal Fear Nuclear Fire
31 91.75 4Testament The Gathering
32 91.67 6Accept Russian Roulette
33 91.67 6Anthrax Spreading the Disease
34 91.61 18Judas Priest Painkiller
35 91.60 5Accept Restless and Wild
36 91.60 5Running Wild Death or Glory
37 91.50 4Heir Apparent One Small Voice
38 91.50 12Judas Priest Hell Bent for Leather
39 91.50 4King Diamond Conspiracy
40 91.50 8Slayer Reign In Blood
41 91.27 11Iron Maiden Iron Maiden
42 91.25 4Obsession Methods of Madness
43 91.25 4Rage Secrets In A Weird World
44 91.20 5Testament The New Order
45 91.20 5UDO Faceless World
46 91.00 4Dream Theater Awake
47 90.80 10Black Sabbath TYR
48 90.62 8Pantera Vulgar Display Of Power
49 90.57 7Slayer South Of Heaven
50 90.56 9Slayer Seasons In The Abyss
51 90.50 6Avantasia The Scarecrow
52 90.50 4Lizzy Borden Master of Disguise
53 90.40 5Helloween Walls of Jericho
54 90.40 5Helloween Master of the Rings
55 90.25 4Venom Black Metal
56 90.00 5Blind Guardian Imaginations From the Other Side
57 90.00 4Candlemass Tales of Creation
58 90.00 4Dream Theater Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory
59 90.00 6Fight War Of Words
60 90.00 9Megadeth Peace Sells... But Who's Buying
61 90.00 4Overkill Under the Influence
62 90.00 8Testament The Legacy
63 89.75 4Iced Earth Dystopia
64 89.75 4Lizzy Borden Love You To Pieces
65 89.75 4Sword Sweet Dreams
66 89.67 6Vicious Rumors Vicious Rumors
67 89.55 11Metallica Metallica
68 89.50 6Black Sabbath Mob Rules
69 89.50 4Vicious Rumors Welcome To The Ball
70 89.44 9Fates Warning Parallels
71 89.43 7Exodus Bonded by Blood
72 89.33 6Halford Resurrection
73 89.25 4Grim Reaper Rock You To Hell
74 89.25 4Motorhead No Sleep 'Til Hammersmith
75 89.25 4Stratovarius Destiny
76 89.20 5Saxon Innocence Is No Excuse
77 89.20 5Testament Practice What You Preach
78 89.12 8Metal Church The Dark
79 89.00 5Judas Priest Firepower
80 89.00 7Queensryche Rage for Order
81 88.88 8Motorhead Ace Of Spades
82 88.75 4Battle Beast Battle Beast
83 88.75 4Exodus Pleasures Of The Flesh
84 88.75 4Queensryche The Warning
85 88.71 7Black Sabbath Seventh Star
86 88.60 5Def Leppard High 'n' Dry
87 88.60 5Edguy Hellfire Club
88 88.58 12Iron Maiden Fear Of The Dark
89 88.50 8Black Sabbath Dehumanizer
90 88.50 6Metallica Garage Inc.
91 88.50 6Sepultura Arise
92 88.43 7Anthrax Among the Living
93 88.43 7Heaven and Hell The Devil You Know
94 88.38 13Metallica Master Of Puppets
95 88.33 15Metallica ...And Justice For All
96 88.25 4Judas Priest 98 Live Meltdown
97 88.25 4Saxon Solid Ball of Rock
98 88.00 13Judas Priest Turbo
99 87.90 10Manowar Sign of the Hammer
100 87.86 7Black Sabbath Black Sabbath
101 87.86 7Black Sabbath Cross Purposes


 

Designed and maintained by Webmaster
© 2000-2025. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy

Top